Free Shipping vs Buyer-Paid Shipping Profit Math
When you roll a $6.50 shipping label into a free-shipping list price, marketplace percentage fees also apply to that extra $6.50. Model the exact difference live.
| Marketplace | Fees | Payout | Net Profit | ROI | Break-Even |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Depop 2026-03-01 | $2.23 | $45.27 | $30.62 | 144.8% | $22.34 |
Facebook Marketplace 2026-03-01 | $2.70 | $44.80 | $30.15 | 142.6% | $22.27 |
Mercari 2026-03-01 | $5.40 | $42.10 | $27.45 | 129.8% | $23.50 |
Etsy 2026-03-01 | $5.58 | $41.92 | $27.27 | 128.9% | $23.87 |
Whatnot 2026-03-01 | $6.19 | $41.31 | $26.66 | 126.1% | $24.08 |
Grailed 2026-03-01 | $7.23 | $40.27 | $25.62 | 121.1% | $24.73 |
eBay 2026-03-01 | $7.74 | $39.76 | $25.11 | 118.7% | $24.95 |
StockX 2026-03-01 | $10.48 | $37.02 | $22.37 | 105.8% | $28.58 |
Poshmark 2026-03-01 | $10.80 | $36.70 | $22.05 | 104.3% | $26.44 |
Accounting and tax worksheets are prepared for CPA review only; not licensed tax, legal, or accounting advice. Marketplace fee schedules are independent and user-editable.
How the fee math works
Because commission applies to item price on every marketplace, absorbing a $6.50 label requires adding Label / (1 - FeeRate) to preserve identical dollar profit.
- Fee-on-Shipping Parity
- On eBay and Etsy, fees already apply to buyer shipping so total fees match either way.
- Poshmark & Mercari Twist
- On Poshmark and Mercari, buyer-paid shipping is excluded from commission, saving 10% to 20% on the postage portion.
- Return Protection
- With buyer-paid shipping, original outbound shipping is easier to separate on buyer-remorse returns.
Aisle & stockroom checklist
- 1 Toggle Buyer Pays Shipping vs Free Shipping above to inspect your exact break-even delta.
- 2 Verify farthest US shipping zone cost before enabling Free Shipping on items over 1 lb.
- 3 Track actual label cost per sold SKU so your tax worksheet deducts every postage dollar.
Preset snapshot ($14.00 buy / $54.00 list)
Related reseller calculators
Mercari Free Shipping Margin & Markup Check
See how offering free shipping on Mercari impacts net profit, ROI, and required list price markup.
eBay Sneaker Seller Fee & Net Profit Calculator
Calculate eBay sneaker seller fees, shipping pass-through impact, net payout, ROI, and break-even list price offline.
Reseller Schedule C COGS & P&L Worksheet Guide
Organize Gross Sales, Platform Fees, Shipping & Supplies, COGS, and Net Profit into clean quarterly worksheets for CPA review.