Etsy Vintage Reseller Profit & Fragile Packing Math
Estate-sale glassware and mid-century decor deliver strong markup, but heavy shipping cartons and breakage buffers matter. Calculate real net profit before buying.
| Marketplace | Fees | Payout | Net Profit | ROI | Break-Even |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Depop 2026-03-01 | $2.56 | $50.64 | $39.84 | 368.9% | $10.81 |
Facebook Marketplace 2026-03-01 | $3.20 | $50.00 | $39.20 | 363.0% | $10.74 |
Whatnot 2026-03-01 | $6.32 | $46.88 | $36.08 | 334.1% | $11.51 |
Mercari 2026-03-01 | $6.40 | $46.80 | $36.00 | 333.3% | $12.00 |
Etsy 2026-03-01 | $6.53 | $46.67 | $35.87 | 332.1% | $12.37 |
Grailed 2026-03-01 | $8.48 | $44.72 | $33.92 | 314.1% | $13.25 |
eBay 2026-03-01 | $9.10 | $44.10 | $33.30 | 308.3% | $13.47 |
StockX 2026-03-01 | $10.24 | $42.96 | $32.16 | 297.8% | $15.46 |
Poshmark 2026-03-01 | $10.40 | $42.80 | $32.00 | 296.3% | $12.55 |
Accounting and tax worksheets are prepared for CPA review only; not licensed tax, legal, or accounting advice. Marketplace fee schedules are independent and user-editable.
How the fee math works
Combines Etsy 9.50% + $0.45 base fees on item + buyer shipping with explicit fragile-packing material costs and thrift COGS.
- Fragile Supply Budget
- Include $2.50 to $3.50 for bubble wrap, kraft paper, and thick shipping boxes.
- Shipping Margin Alignment
- Because Etsy charges 9.5% on buyer shipping too, undercharging postage erodes item profit.
- Estate Lot COGS Split
- Switch to the Haul Receipt COGS Splitter tab to allocate box-lot auction receipts accurately.
Aisle & stockroom checklist
- 1 Run a fingernail along glass rims and stoneware spouts to catch hairline chips.
- 2 Pack fragile items in dedicated rigid stockroom bins (e.g. D-01) with clear bin labels.
- 3 Keep original estate-sale receipt totals matched to exact SKU COGS for CPA review.
Preset snapshot ($8.00 buy / $52.00 list)
Related reseller calculators
Etsy Transaction, Payment & Listing Fee Calculator
Calculate Etsy transaction fees, 3% + $0.25 payment processing, $0.20 listing renewal fee, and optional offsite ad fees.
Weighted vs Even COGS Allocation for Mixed Lots
Compare even per-piece splitting vs value-weighted COGS allocation when buying mixed estate boxes or thrift lots.
Garage & Stockroom Bin QR Inventory System (A-01 to Z-99)
Organize garage and spare-room reseller stockrooms with A-01 to Z-99 bin codes, printable QR labels, and fast barcode lookup.